91 Main St
New Paltz, NY 12561
P&G’s waitstaff has always been friendly and accommodating. I’ve never had a problem explaining my wheat allergy and getting awesome substitutes in return.
I love their very reasonable “2 for $20” special for Monday dinner. One appetizer + two entrees for $20 = one of the best deals in New Paltz!
P&G’s doubles as a bar in the evenings. It’s dark and can get kind of loud. Great for family and low-key gatherings. Think small-town Friendly’s. It’s not fantastic, but I keep coming back for the service and the food. If you get a booth by the window, it’s actually pretty cozy. Just don’t plan on going there late at night on Friday or Saturday or you’ll be faced with the hordes of dancing college students.
Gluten free bread is only 75 cents extra here! Total steal for a surcharge! I love getting the same sandwiches and burgers as everyone else. It’s no frills pub food, but it’s delicious. Please note, they’ve told me their fries are not gluten free — but they’re also not fried in the same fryer as their breaded items. So, safe for wheat allergy — but not so if you have Celiac disease. You can sub a baked potato or one of their other sides without any issues.
We substituted the normal tortilla chips served with the spinach and artichoke dip for corn chips, thanks to our server.
Close up of the spinach and artichoke, a bowl of cheesy goodness:
I ordered the P&G’s burger with Swiss for my entree, with the gluten free bread. It was a standard, pretty large burger with a generous serving of fries (sorry…no photo…slacking blogger here.)
I’d easily recommend P&G’s. It’s a great pit stop for some comfort food.